RANKING: I need to eat more kaiseki meals to be
confident about rankings. This said, I
think three Michelin stars to Kitcho is fully justified. But I am puzzled by only two stars to
Nakamura. My meal at Nakamura was an
unforgettable experience. Only a handful
of the chefs in the world can perform at this level of precision and
sophistication.
DATE
VISITED: March 21 and 22, 2010,
respectively.
PHONES:
Kitcho 075 881 1101 Nakamura 075 221
5511
SUMMARY: Japanese haute cuisine, the kaiseki meal, is
a must if you visit Kyoto. At its best,
it is subtle, rigorous, harmonious, appeals to the eye and taste buds, and the
course of the meal is driven by the availability of the best ingredients on the
day you visit the restaurant. (So the
word ‘seasonal’ or the cliché ‘farm to table’ remain inadequate.) I was taken aback by how much discretion chefs
enjoy when designing exclusive kaiseki feasts for their guests. At Kitcho in Arashiyama, the chef-owner
Tokuoka-san works like a calligrapher, his style is quite restrained, and it is
easier to appreciate him when his whole work is complete rather than on a dish
by dish basis. Nakamura-san, on the
other hand, is capable of making some bold statements, and his cuisine is quite
lusty by Japanese-kaiseki standards. One
thing that unites the two chefs is their absolute commitment to their
profession and their attention to detail.